Which is cheaper, the Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver or the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1?

The Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver is currently the cheaper of the two, with a lowest listed price of $123.85 compared with $654.99 for the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1. Dealer prices are live and can change.

Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver vs Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1

The short answer

The Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver and the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1 are both single action revolvers. The Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver is the more affordable option, starting at $123.85 versus $654.99. On the spec sheet, the Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver is lighter (30.6 oz vs 40 oz).

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver and the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1?: They differ mainly in caliber (.22 LR vs .357 Magnum), barrel length (4.75" vs 5"), overall length (10.03" vs 11.1") and weight (30.6 oz vs 40 oz).
Which is cheaper, the Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver or the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1?: The Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver is currently the cheaper of the two, with a lowest listed price of $123.85 compared with $654.99 for the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1. Dealer prices are live and can change.
Are the Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver and the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1 the same caliber?: No. The Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver is .22 LR and the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1 is .357 Magnum.

	Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver Single Action Revolvers $123.85	Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1 taylors and co · Single Action Revolvers $654.99
Caliber	.22 LR	.357 Magnum
Capacity	6 rounds	6 rounds
Barrel length	4.75"	5"
Overall length	10.03"	11.1"
Weight	30.6 oz	40 oz
Action	Single Action	Single Action
Finish	Black Cerakote	Blue
Frame material	Black Polymer	Checkered Walnut
Frame size	N/A	Standard
Sights	Fixed Front / Notched Rear	Fixed Front, Notch Rear
Safety	Hammer / Thumb	N/A

Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver

Single Action Revolvers

$123.85

Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1

taylors and co · Single Action Revolvers

$654.99

Caliber

.22 LR

.357 Magnum

Capacity

6 rounds

Barrel length

4.75"

Overall length

10.03"

11.1"

Weight

30.6 oz

40 oz

Action

Single Action

Finish

Black Cerakote

Blue

Frame material

Black Polymer

Checkered Walnut

Frame size

N/A

Standard

Sights

Fixed Front / Notched Rear

Fixed Front, Notch Rear

Safety

Hammer / Thumb

N/A

Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver vs Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1

The short answer

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver and the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1?: They differ mainly in caliber (.22 LR vs .357 Magnum), barrel length (4.75" vs 5"), overall length (10.03" vs 11.1") and weight (30.6 oz vs 40 oz).
Which is cheaper, the Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver or the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1?: The Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver is currently the cheaper of the two, with a lowest listed price of $123.85 compared with $654.99 for the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1. Dealer prices are live and can change.
Are the Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver and the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1 the same caliber?: No. The Heritage Rough Rider 4.75" .22LR Classic Black SA Revolver is .22 LR and the Taylors & Co. Smoke Wagon .357 Magnum SA Revolver 5.5" - Gen 1 is .357 Magnum.