The Ninth Circuit on November 20, 2026, revived a San Diego man's lawsuit over the loss of his concealed-carry license because of his motorcycle-club affiliation. In Shilling v. County of San Diego, the court reversed the dismissal of Kenneth Charles Shilling's constitutional claims and sent the case back for further proceedings. The decision allows the suit to continue; it does not restore his expired license or award damages.
Judge Patrick J. Bumatay wrote the published opinion for a panel that also included Judges Kenneth K. Lee and Jennifer Sung. Shilling sued the County of San Diego and Sheriff Kelly Martinez in her official capacity under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. He alleged violations of both his First Amendment freedom of association and his Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms.
Shilling received his license in June 2022 from then-Sheriff Anthony Ray. Martinez revoked it in December 2023 under the county's definition of “good moral character,” citing his association with the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club. Her letter called the club a “criminal street gang.” Shilling disputed that characterization, describing a lawful organization involved in charitable and community activities. The appeal addressed whether his allegations could proceed; it was not a trial resolving the club's activities.
Invalid Date
More Articles
The sheriff and county remain defendants
The district court had treated the sheriff as immune from suit under the Eleventh Amendment and dismissed the county because it viewed license revocation as state policy. The appellate panel rejected both grounds, addressing them as separate questions. Its immunity analysis examined the sheriff's office as an entity, while its county-liability analysis examined the particular discretion Martinez exercised in revoking Shilling's license.
On immunity, the panel held that California sheriffs are not arms of the state. It emphasized their legal independence under California law, the absence of formal state responsibility for judgments against them, and the division of supervisory authority. Sheriffs are county officers, and counties control important aspects of their offices and finances. Although California's attorney general has supervisory powers, the panel found those powers insufficient to overcome the evidence of legal separation from the state.
County liability turned on who defined and enforced the old moral-character standard. State law had left that term undefined, and Martinez's department supplied its own definition, including a connection to a criminal gang. The panel concluded that she acted as the county's final policymaker in applying that standard. Uniform statewide application forms, fingerprint requirements and reporting duties did not turn her discretionary revocation decision into state policy. The county can therefore face liability, though liability has not been established.
Expiration did not erase the records claim
California replaced the good-moral-character requirement with a dangerousness-based exclusion effective January 1, 2024, shortly after the revocation. Shilling's license also expired. Those developments eliminated two requested remedies: immediate return of the license and an injunction against revocations without proof of a crime or specific gang-related activity. But Shilling had also asked the court to destroy the records of his revocation, a request the appellate panel found still capable of providing effective relief.
Shilling alleged that those records could make it harder to obtain another carry license and could appear in criminal background checks. If he establishes a Second Amendment violation, the district court could address those continuing effects by ordering the records destroyed. That is why the panel held his claim for injunctive relief was not moot. It did not itself order deletion or decide that the underlying revocation violated the Second Amendment.
Association claim clears the pleading stage
The panel also reinstated Shilling's First Amendment claim. His allegation that officials revoked a license solely because he belonged to a lawful group was sufficient to proceed. The district court had focused on whether the revocation prevented him from joining the club or participating in its activities. The appellate court explained that denying a benefit or right because of association can infringe that freedom even without preventing participation in the organization.
For the association-based deprivation at issue, the opinion says the government must establish both the group's unlawful goals and the individual's specific intent to further those goals. Shilling must still litigate his claims on remand in the Southern District of California. Whether he will obtain damages or destruction of the revocation records remains unresolved, and the opinion sets no date for the next district-court proceeding.
About the Author
Nick Sawinyh - Nick Sawinyh is a father, husband, hobby farmer, and gun enthusiast from Kentucky. He founded GunsNation and writes most of what appears on this blog.