The Taylor's & Co. 1873 Cattleman is a single-action revolver built around the classic SAO design, aimed at cowboy action shooters, collectors, and anyone wanting a historically styled sidearm for range use or reenactments. The case-hardened frame and walnut grip give it a period-correct look without sacrificing function. 
 

Key Specifications 

• Brand: Taylor's & Co. 
• Model Name: 1873 Cattleman 
• SKU: 1794002667 
• UPC: 839665001110 
• Caliber: .45 Colt (LC) 
• Action: Single Action Only (SAO) 
• Capacity: 6 Rounds 
• Barrel Length: 7.5 inches 
• Overall Length: 13 inches 
• Weight: 2.5 lbs (40 oz) 
• Sights: Blade Front & Notched Rear 
• Grip Material: Walnut 
• Frame Finish: Case Hardened Steel 
   

Detailed Features 

 
The SAO action requires cocking the hammer before each shot, which keeps the trigger pull consistent and relatively light — a useful trait in cowboy action competition where split-second timing matters. 
 
Chambered in .45 Colt, the Cattleman delivers the caliber's well-known stopping power with recoil that most shooters find manageable. The walnut grip fits the hand naturally and holds up through extended range sessions. Blade front and notched rear sights are the traditional arrangement for this platform, straightforward for close-to-mid-range work. 
 
The blued barrel pairs with the case-hardened frame, giving the revolver its distinctive two-tone period appearance while protecting the steel from everyday wear. 
 

Target Audience 

 
This revolver suits cowboy action competitors who want an authentic-feeling gun that actually runs, as well as collectors who prefer their historical pieces to be shootable. It also works for casual recreational shooting where the .45 Colt chambering is an asset rather than a liability. 
 

Usage Scenarios 

 
At a cowboy action stage, the smooth trigger and 6-round cylinder let you work through targets at a solid pace. On a weekend hunt, the .45 Colt's power is adequate for many applications. At home, the combination of reliability and simple manual of arms makes it a viable option for anyone already comfortable with single-action revolvers.

Owners of the Taylor's 1873 Cattleman .45 Colt tend to split between genuine enthusiasm for what it is and measured skepticism about some practical trade-offs.

Positive Sentiments:

1. Aesthetic Appeal: The case-hardened finish gets consistent praise for looking authentically period-correct. Collectors in particular appreciate how closely it mirrors the original design.

2. Build Quality: Most users describe the revolver as solid and well-fitted, which translates to confidence when handling it.

3. Shooting Experience: The trigger pull draws favorable comments — smooth and consistent, which matters in cowboy action competition and just makes range sessions more enjoyable.

4. Historical Significance: The connection to the Old West adds genuine sentimental value for a lot of owners, beyond the gun's function.

Critical Sentiments:

1. Price Point: Several buyers flag that the Cattleman costs more than comparable SAO revolvers, which prompts debate about whether the Taylor's name and finish justify the premium for casual shooters.

2. Performance Issues: A handful of reviews mention reliability concerns — misfires or cylinder alignment problems after extended use. These aren't universal, but they do come up often enough to note.

3. Caliber Considerations: Most owners embrace the .45 Colt, but some wish for additional caliber options, and a few question its practicality for modern defensive use.

4. Weight and Size: At 40 oz with a 7.5-inch barrel, this is a large revolver. Some users find that less appealing for carry or longer range sessions compared to lighter contemporary designs.