The Taylor's & Co. 1873 Comanchero is a lever-action rifle chambered in .45 Colt, with a 20-inch octagonal barrel and color case-hardened steel finish. The checkered walnut stock has a straight grip. At 7.90 lbs and 39 inches overall, it's a compact, handy rifle that fits the cowboy action and Western shooting crowd well. 
 

Key Specifications 

• Model: 1873 Comanchero 
• Caliber: .45 Colt (LC) 
• Action: Lever Action 
• Barrel Length: 20 inches 
• Capacity: 10+1 rounds 
• Weight: 7.90 lbs 
• Overall Length (OAL): 39 inches 
• Sights: Blade Front and Buckhorn Rear 
• Stock Material: Walnut with a Checkered Straight Type 
• Finish: Color Case Hardened Steel 
   

Features 

 
The lever action cycles smoothly. The octagonal barrel is a nod to the original 1873 Winchester design and is functional as well as aesthetic. Blade front and buckhorn rear sights are appropriate for the rifle's intended use range. The color case hardening is well-executed on these, which makes it attractive in the hand. 
 

Usage 

 
The .45 Colt is an effective cartridge for hunting deer-sized game at moderate distances and handles well in cowboy action shooting competitions. Some owners find the factory sights limiting for precision work at longer ranges and swap them out for improved options. At 7.90 lbs the rifle has some weight to it, which aids stability but can be tiring on extended carries.

Owners of the Taylor's 1873 Comanchero in .45 LC are generally pleased with it, particularly those who shoot cowboy action or collect lever guns.

The look gets consistent compliments. The octagonal barrel and color case hardening make a strong visual impression. The lever action is smooth and the rifle is reliable in use. The .45 Colt caliber is valued for manageable recoil and flexibility between hunting and competition shooting.

Practical criticisms are fairly consistent. The factory sights are adequate but not precise enough for some shooters at distance, and several owners mention upgrading them. The weight is also noted. 7.90 lbs is on the heavier end for a 20-inch lever gun, which some find tiring.

Accuracy at typical handgun ranges is considered good. Overall this rifle is well-regarded by its intended audience.