The Cimarron 1866 Yellowboy Gen II in .45 Colt consistently draws positive comments on its appearance, particularly the brass receiver and walnut stock combination that closely mirrors the original 1866 design.
Shooting performance is generally well-reported. The lever action is smooth, and the .45 Colt caliber handles a range of loads predictably. Owners involved in cowboy action shooting find it well-suited to the sport. For casual target shooting and ranch use it works without issue.
The recurring criticisms are weight during extended carry and the price point relative to alternatives, though most buyers consider the aesthetics and historical fidelity worth the cost. Availability of replacement parts is occasionally mentioned as a concern. It's not the right choice for someone wanting a modern tactical lever gun, but for traditional lever-action use it's consistently recommended.
AI-generated insights derived from customer reviews and discussions on popular gun-enthusiast forums.